Over the years, working with countless collectors and exotic car owners, I’ve seen firsthand that these vehicles aren’t just transportation, their investments, passions, and pieces of family history. So, when something unexpected happens, the emotional and financial stakes are a lot higher.

Understanding the Stakes

A rare or exotic car holds value far beyond what the market shows. It’s about provenance, unique features, and how the car’s been cared for over time. In this space, documentation and agreed value policies aren’t just important, they’re essential. Standard policies often miss the mark because they don’t account for what makes these cars unique. They depreciate based on age and condition alone.

I worked with a client who was on his third McLaren. He had it on a standard daily driving policy. When we reviewed his coverage, we noticed low limits for property damage and uninsured/underinsured motorists, and no endorsement for OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) parts. I explained the gaps, and while he agreed, he wasn’t ready to make the switch because “it was working.”

A few months later, he called. This time, frustrated. He’d been in a not-at-fault accident, and the claims process was a nightmare. The underinsured motorist who hit him had the same carrier, and they were minimizing the damage. His car was misunderstood, undervalued, and the policy he once thought was “good enough” fell short. That moment made it clear: having the right policy could have changed everything.

The First Steps After an Accident

An accident involving a car you love can be gut-wrenching. If everyone’s safe, take a deep breath. Then call the police, even if the accident seems minor. A formal report helps tell your side of the story.

Start documenting immediately. Take photos of the damage, your car’s unique features, and the scene. Include everything, intersections, merging lanes, anything that helps paint a clear picture.

Reach out to your insurance provider promptly. If they’re not familiar with specialty vehicles, be ready to provide detailed documentation yourself.

Choosing the Right Repair Partner

When your car is rare, exotic, or historically significant, choosing a repair shop is about more than just fixing damage, it’s about preserving provenance. These vehicles carry a history that can be lost if a repair isn’t done with intention and precision.

It's not just about dents and dings. A proper repair on a collector car must be part restoration, part preservation. The wrong shop could erase decades of care and originality by using non-OEM parts, skipping manufacturer procedures, or failing to document the work.

For example, take rims. If one is damaged, “pair and set” coverage ensures the matching rim is replaced too, preserving both performance and visual continuity. But the stakes are even higher when it comes to paint matching, body panels, carbon fiber components, or specialty finishes. Using original paint codes, factory-correct badges, and authentic materials isn’t just about aesthetics; it’s about maintaining the story your car tells.

A qualified shop will understand the historical and collectible importance of your vehicle. They’ll document every step of the process, use OEM or period-correct parts, and know that a repair on a 1962 Ferrari 250 GTO or an anniversary edition Porsche isn't just a fix, it's a continuation of the car’s legacy.

Always get multiple expert estimates, and if needed, bring in a marquee-specific specialist. Your insurance partner should support this process, not shortcut it. After all, with collector vehicles, value isn't just measured by market price, it's embedded in authenticity.

Navigating the Claims Process

Claims involving specialty cars are rarely straightforward. Adjusters may not understand collector cars and might undervalue both your vehicle and the necessary repairs.

That’s where documentation makes all the difference. A professional appraisal can shift the conversation. If your car is declared a total loss, you might have the option to buy it back, but know that comes with a salvage title, which impacts resale and future insurability.

Being organized and working with experts gives you the best chance at a fair outcome.

Understanding Valuation and Negotiating Your Claim

How your car’s value is determined affects your payout. Agreed value policies guarantee the payout amount. Stated value policies carry more risk, and actual cash value often leaves you short due to depreciation.

Negotiation is not about arguing; it is about providing evidence: photos, appraisals, repair estimates. Do not forget to ask if sales tax applies and include extras like paint protection film, ceramic coatings, or wraps, they matter too.

Diminished Value: What Happens After Repairs

Even with perfect repairs, your car may lose value simply because it’s been in an accident. That’s diminished value, and it’s often overlooked.

You’ll need before-and-after appraisals, photos, invoices. The more proof, the better your chances of recovering this loss.

Planning Ahead: Lessons for the Future

Protecting your car is an ongoing process. Review your policy every year. Keep your records up to date. Consider adding a dashcam, it can be critical when fault is questioned.

Keep a claims-prep kit in the car: flares, first aid supplies, and copies of your insurance and registration. Anti-theft and tracking devices can not only reduce your risk, they may reduce your premium too.

At the end of the day, the right insurance paired with preparation is your best defense. If you own or drive a rare or exotic vehicle, this isn’t just about paperwork. It’s about protecting what matters most to you.

____

Written by Dana Acabbo & Stephen Mills